Autism, communication, AI and the expectation that the disabled person must always adapt.
“Well, you could have said it differently.”
That’s what a fellow Samaritans volunteer said to me recently after I’d stated something in a perfectly matter-of-fact manner.
I hadn’t dressed it up in rainbows and unicorns. I’d simply said what I meant.
And my immediate thought was, hang on a minute.
I’m autistic. When I was diagnosed in 2014, autism was commonly described in terms of what was known as the triad of impairments. One of those three defining areas of difficulty was social communication.
The terminology has since changed, and modern diagnostic frameworks group things somewhat differently, but communication difficulties remain a central characteristic of autism.
So here I am, somebody with a diagnosed disability, one of whose documented impairments concerns communication, being told that I should have communicated differently.
Does anybody else see the irony here?
Why is the expectation that I should have said something differently? Why isn’t there equal consideration given to the possibility that somebody could have received it differently, interpreted it differently, or simply chosen to react differently?
Why is it automatically the person with the disability who is expected to make the adjustment?
When Accessibility Only Works One Way
To my mind, that’s rather like telling somebody in a wheelchair, when they discover the lift isn’t working, “Well, you could just walk up the stairs, couldn’t you?”
We’d recognise how absurd that suggestion was.
We have accessibility ramps and lifts for people with physical disabilities. We have induction loops for people who are hard of hearing. We have assistance dogs for people who are blind, and for people with other disabilities.
In other words, we recognise that people with disabilities sometimes need society to make adjustments to accommodate them.
We don’t generally expect somebody in a wheelchair to learn how to climb stairs. We don’t tell somebody who’s hard of hearing that they simply need to listen more carefully.
Yet when it comes to autism, particularly the communication difficulties that are part of the condition, the expectation so often seems to be that the autistic person must change.
Not the people listening. Not the people interpreting what was said. Not the people making assumptions about somebody else’s intentions.
The autistic person.
And that’s what I find so fundamentally contradictory about the whole thing.
I’m not suggesting that being autistic gives me the right to say whatever I like, however I like, without considering other people.
But surely consideration works both ways?
If I communicate something directly, without any hidden meaning or intended offence, why should the immediate assumption be that I’ve communicated badly, rather than that somebody else has interpreted it in a way I never intended?
Surely accessibility isn’t exclusively about ramps, lifts and physical adaptations. Sometimes it’s about other people being willing to understand that not everybody communicates in the same way.
AI: An Accessibility Tool I Never Knew I Needed
And then, just recently, I had another example of precisely this.
Early one morning, I sent an email concerning an urgent matter within my Samaritans branch.
Later that evening, I was told that the email had come across as condescending and patronising, and that it was very clearly AI-generated.
And my immediate thought was, and?
So what if I’d used AI?
What exactly do people imagine happens? That I’m sitting at home when suddenly there’s a tap at the window and an AI announces, “Hey, I’ve had this brilliant idea. Here’s an email you should send”?
Of course not.
I spent approximately two hours in the early hours of the morning working on that email, going backwards and forwards with AI, discussing the issues, explaining my reasoning, refining the wording and making sure it communicated what I wanted to say.
The thoughts were mine. The concerns were mine. The arguments were mine. The decisions about what to include were mine.
AI helped me put them into words.
How is that fundamentally different from an author working with an editor, or somebody dictating their thoughts to a secretary who then produces a properly structured letter?
Yet apparently, the fact that the email was written in well-structured, fairly neutral, proper English made it sound condescending and patronising.
Perhaps they were expecting something that sounded more like the way I actually speak. A fairly common-speaking, Northern-sounding bloke who was dragged up in Stoke and now lives in Bolton. Not somebody writing in polished, grammatically correct English.
But surely that’s the whole point of using AI to help me communicate?
But here’s what I find particularly frustrating about that criticism.
AI has been an absolute game changer for me as an autistic person.
It doesn’t just help me write things. It helps me understand what I’m actually thinking and feeling in the first place.
That’s an important distinction.
Alongside autism, I experience alexithymia, which means I can have difficulty identifying and describing my own emotions.
Sometimes I know something is bothering me, but I struggle to identify exactly what it is or articulate why.
I can spend hours having a conversation with AI, examining my thoughts, challenging them, pulling them apart and eventually arriving at a point where I understand what I wanted to communicate all along.
Only then can I communicate it effectively to somebody else.
For somebody whose disability includes difficulties with communication, that’s an extraordinary tool to have available.
And yet, when I use that tool to help overcome those difficulties, the response can still be that I haven’t communicated in an acceptable way.
If I communicate directly, I’m told I could have said it differently.
If I use AI to help me communicate differently, I’m told the result sounds patronising, condescending and obviously AI-generated.
So what exactly am I supposed to do?
We accept that somebody with a physical disability might use equipment to overcome a physical barrier. We accept hearing aids, induction loops and other assistive technologies without expecting people to apologise for using them.
But when an autistic person uses technology to help overcome a communication barrier, suddenly the technology itself becomes part of the criticism.
I’m not claiming that AI always produces perfect writing, or that something I’ve written can’t genuinely come across differently from how I intended. Of course it can.
But surely the important thing should be the substance of what somebody is communicating, rather than whether they needed assistance to communicate it?
For me, AI isn’t simply a convenient way of writing emails. It’s a tool that helps me communicate with a world that so often tells me I’m doing it wrong.
When the Structure of an Organisation Makes All the Difference
There’s another aspect to this that I find particularly interesting.
I’ve spent around 40 years volunteering with the RAF Air Cadets, an organisation with a clearly defined hierarchy, rank structure and established chain of command.
Everybody understood their responsibilities, who had authority to make decisions and where accountability lay.
I didn’t encounter these same difficulties there.
I could communicate in a straightforward, matter-of-fact manner, and people generally accepted it for what it was.
There were rules, procedures and clearly defined expectations. If something needed doing, it was generally understood who was responsible for doing it and who had the authority to make the decision.
That structure worked for me.
Compare that with an organisation where authority is less clearly defined, where decision-making relies heavily on consensus, and where unwritten social expectations can sometimes carry as much weight as formal responsibilities.
Suddenly, it isn’t necessarily enough to know what needs doing or what the rules say.
You also have to navigate personalities, interpretations, sensitivities and how people might feel about the way something has been communicated.
For somebody like me, who values clarity, consistency, predictability and straightforward communication, that can become exhausting.
And I think that’s an important distinction.
I don’t need somebody telling me what to do. I need to know what my responsibilities are, what authority I have and what is expected of me.
I’ve held positions of responsibility for much of my adult life. I’m perfectly capable of making decisions, managing people and dealing with difficult situations.
But the environment in which I’m expected to exercise those responsibilities makes an enormous difference.
I’ve increasingly come to believe that people like me can find positions of responsibility particularly difficult within organisations that lack clearly defined hierarchical structures.
Not because we lack the ability to lead, but because so much of our energy can be consumed by navigating ambiguity that has very little to do with the actual job.
The Irony of Being a Samaritan
And there’s another irony here that I find difficult to ignore.
Samaritans is an organisation built around listening, understanding people, accepting them without judgement and providing emotional support.
As a listening volunteer myself, I know just how seriously we take those principles.
I’ve spent years listening to people who are struggling, sometimes with things they find incredibly difficult to put into words.
I’ve even had callers tell me at the end of conversations that I’m different, that they’ve really felt listened to.
I’ve often wondered whether my autism actually contributes something positive to the way I listen.
I tend to take people at face value. I don’t necessarily respond in the way somebody might expect, and I approach conversations in a fairly direct, matter-of-fact way.
That doesn’t mean I lack empathy or understanding. It means my way of expressing those things can be different.
And sometimes, that difference seems to be precisely what somebody needs.
But there’s an important distinction between the listening service we provide to callers and the way we sometimes communicate and work with one another behind the scenes.
It’s within that internal organisational environment that I’ve encountered these difficulties.
And I do find it ironic that an organisation whose volunteers are trained to listen without judgement can sometimes struggle to apply those same principles in its own internal relationships.
I want to be absolutely clear about something here.
None of this should discourage anybody from contacting Samaritans.
The difficulties I’m describing concern my personal experience of internal organisational relationships and management. They aren’t a reflection of the support offered to people who contact the service.
I’ve worked alongside some extraordinary listening volunteers, people who give their time to support complete strangers, often during the most difficult moments of their lives.
I remain proud to be one of them.
And it’s precisely because I believe in that work that I think we should be willing to examine how we treat and understand one another.
I’m not asking anybody to agree with everything I say. I’m not asking for special treatment or suggesting that my words should never be challenged.
I’m simply asking for the same consideration and understanding that we’re supposed to extend to the people who contact us.
Surely that shouldn’t be an unreasonable expectation.
When the Personal Cost Becomes Too Great
In any case, it’s off the back of all of this that I’ve now sent an email saying that I wish to stand down as Co-Director of my Samaritans branch.
Quite simply, it just isn’t worth it anymore.
And that’s not a decision I’ve taken because I don’t care.
Quite the opposite.
I’ve invested an enormous amount of time and effort into the organisation, its volunteers and the people we’re there to support.
But I’ve reached a point where the difficulties involved in trying to fulfil that responsibility have become more exhausting than the responsibility itself.
I’ve spent decades successfully operating within organisations where responsibilities, authority and expectations were clearly defined.
Yet here I am, finding that one of the greatest difficulties I face in a position of responsibility isn’t making decisions, dealing with urgent problems or taking responsibility for difficult situations.
It’s how other people interpret the way I communicate.
And after years of trying to understand myself, my autism and the way I interact with the world, I find that particularly frustrating.
Because the message I seem to keep receiving is remarkably consistent.
You could have said it differently.
You could have written it differently.
You could have approached it differently.
You could have considered how somebody else might interpret it.
And perhaps I could.
But at what point does somebody stop and consider that perhaps the other person could also have listened differently, interpreted it differently or approached it differently?
At what point does the responsibility become shared?
Reasonable adjustments shouldn’t simply mean teaching disabled people to behave more like everybody else. Sometimes they should mean everybody else making an adjustment in how they understand disabled people.
I’ve spent much of my life learning how to adapt to a world that wasn’t designed with people like me in mind.
I don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect that world to occasionally meet me halfway.
And perhaps that’s what disappoints me most about having reached the decision to stand down.
I’m not stepping away because I can’t do the job.
I’m stepping away because, for me, the personal cost of continually having to justify how I do it has finally become too great.