This week I stood down as co-director of my Samaritans branch, halfway through my tenure. It was a role I initially enjoyed, but over time I came to feel that I was bad for the branch.
The way I communicate, and the way people sometimes interpret that communication, was creating an atmosphere, and I didn’t think that was doing the branch any good.
I don’t believe anybody deliberately set out to treat me badly. I genuinely don’t. And I don’t think those people even realise that they’ve treated me badly. That was never their intention.
But it’s made me think about something I’ve experienced throughout my life, particularly during my time in the Air Cadets, at work and more recently with Samaritans.
And I’ve been trying to put that into words.
There is a distinction between someone deliberately discriminating against me and somebody treating me unfairly because they don’t understand me.
When somebody who isn’t autistic comes across as abrupt, obstructive, dismissive or difficult, people tend to interpret that behaviour through their own experience. They assume the person is behaving that way for the same reasons they might behave that way.
But that assumption doesn’t necessarily work with me.
I might be questioning something because I genuinely cannot see the logic in it. I might be speaking plainly because, to me, clarity is more important than social cushioning. I might persist with a point because the question hasn’t actually been answered.
Meanwhile, somebody else interprets exactly the same behaviour as challenging their authority, being deliberately awkward or showing disrespect.
They’re judging my intentions from my behaviour, using their own neurology as the reference point.
And I think this is one of the fundamental problems with hidden disabilities. Because they’re hidden, people aren’t necessarily aware of them in the first place. And even when they are, it’s easy to forget. They see somebody who looks like them, behaves much like them and appears perfectly ordinary, so they naturally assume that person thinks and experiences the world in much the same way they do.
It’s what I’ve come to think of as the assumption of sameness. It’s not necessarily that people have a negative attitude towards hidden disabilities. Often, they’re not even thinking about the disability at all. And I think that’s an important distinction.
And yet I extend to those people precisely the consideration I feel I haven’t always been given myself. I allow for the possibility that their behaviour isn’t malicious, that they’re acting from misunderstanding rather than ill intent.
That doesn’t make them a bad person, but it doesn’t necessarily make their treatment of me fair either.
I’m not asking people to excuse everything I say or do because I’m autistic. I’m asking them to consider that what they perceive as my intention might not actually be my intention at all. And I think that’s a reasonable request.
Discrimination is very nuanced. I can distinguish between someone treating me badly because I’m autistic and somebody treating me badly because they don’t understand how my autism affects me.
To me, they are fundamentally different things. The first involves intent, the second involves ignorance, misunderstanding or simply just being human.
I’m prepared to give people considerable latitude for the second because I recognise that everybody has their own problems, pressures and preoccupations. I don’t expect people to spend their lives accommodating me.
But what happens when I’ve explained myself repeatedly that I’m autistic, like I’m a broken record, and people continue making exactly the same assumptions about my intentions?
That’s where I think my argument becomes particularly interesting.
The first time someone mistakes my directness for hostility, that’s understandable. The second time, perhaps they’ve forgotten my explanation. But when it becomes a recurring pattern over years despite my attempts to explain myself, at what point does understandable ignorance become an unwillingness to understand?
And I’m not suggesting that makes anybody malicious. I accept there’s a distinction between deliberate discrimination and unequal treatment.
But there is a difference between expecting people to remember I’m autistic every moment of their lives and expecting them to remember it when they’re making judgements about my character, motives or intentions.
And that last point gets to the heart of what I’m saying.
When I remind somebody that I’m autistic, I’m not asking them to overlook what happened. I’m asking them to reconsider why it happened before deciding what it says about me.
That’s not asking to be the centre of attention. It’s asking to be understood.
And I genuinely don’t know whether people actually forget that I’m autistic or whether they don’t really understand what it means in practice.
I actually think it’s both.
People just don’t understand. And we can do all this EDI training, but it’s never going to give anybody that isn’t neurodivergent any kind of understanding. Even those that think they understand, they can’t possibly understand.
But I don’t expect anybody to experience the world the way I do. I don’t expect them to understand what it feels like to be autistic.
What I do think is reasonable is that when I explain why I’ve said or done something, people at least consider that explanation rather than continuing to make their own assumptions about my intentions.
Because ultimately, I think I know rather more about what I intended than somebody who has decided what my intentions must have been.
And there’s something else I find rather ironic about all this.
We talk about EDI, about understanding neurodiversity and making accommodations for people like me. Yet I go through life constantly making accommodations for other people.
I make allowances for their misunderstandings, their assumptions, their reactions and the fact that they don’t experience the world the way I do.
And I don’t resent doing that. I genuinely don’t. It’s part of being human.
But I do sometimes wonder why that understanding seems to work in only one direction.
And eventually you reach a point where you think, well, what do I do? Do I try to resolve things informally? Do I make a formal complaint?
But then I come back to the same thing. I don’t believe there’s any malicious intent here. It’s a lack of understanding. It’s that assumption of sameness I’ve been talking about.
And I can imagine how either approach might be received. It would look like I was throwing all my teddies out of the pram, and I think it would only create resentment. And resentment certainly isn’t going to lead to understanding. You can’t force people to understand.
So you look at things in the round. You consider what’s best for everybody, not just yourself. And you realise that sometimes the only way to resolve the situation is to remove yourself.
Because, ultimately, you’re the problem.
And I actually think recognising that, and being prepared to step aside for the good of the branch, is a sign of good leadership.
And there’s one final thing I keep coming back to.
The next time I’m listening to a caller who tells me they’re autistic, and I’m struggling to understand why they’re saying something or why they’re reacting in a particular way, what do I do?
I listen. I try to understand. I don’t judge.
And we do that with all of our callers, regardless of whether they’re autistic or not.
It’s what we’re trained to do as Samaritans volunteers. It’s what we pride ourselves on doing.
So why is it that we can offer that understanding, patience and absence of judgement to complete strangers, sometimes for hours at a time, yet struggle to extend exactly the same consideration to the people around us?
And I don’t think that’s a question limited to Samaritans. It’s something I’ve experienced throughout my life, and I think it comes back to that assumption of sameness. We naturally judge other people’s intentions by how we ourselves would think or behave, forgetting that somebody else might experience the world very differently.
I think that’s something worth reflecting on.